It’s important to know when your climbing shoes need replacing instead of simply being resoled. While resoling can extend their lifespan, there comes a point where the overall wear compromises their effectiveness and comfort. Here are the key signs that it might be time to invest in a new pair:
1. Severe Wear to the Upper or Shoe Structure
If the upper part of your climbing shoes (fabric, leather, or synthetic materials) starts to tear, deform, or lose its original shape, they may no longer provide the necessary support and fit for climbing.
If the internal structure—such as the heel or toe box—is damaged or misshapen, this affects performance and cannot be fixed with a resole.
2. Loss of Shape and Fit
Over time, climbing shoes can lose their snug, form-fitting shape, which is essential for precision.
If they no longer fit properly—even after being resoled—this can reduce your accuracy and safety.
When the shoe becomes too stretched or loose to perform efficiently, it’s likely time to replace them.
3. Damage to the Midsole
If the wear reaches the midsole (the layer between the outer sole and upper), it means the shoe has sustained deep structural damage. At this stage, resoling is no longer effective since the core support of the shoe is compromised.
4. Discomfort or Pain
If your climbing shoes become uncomfortable or painful after long use—especially if the internal padding has worn out—they can negatively affect your climbing experience. Persistent discomfort is a valid reason to upgrade.
5. Multiple Resolings
If you’ve had your shoes resoled multiple times and still notice a decline in overall performance, it might be time for a new pair. Each resole can slightly alter the shape and fit, and while it’s a good temporary solution, it’s not sustainable forever.
6. Irreparable Damage
Major issues like torn seams, damaged heel material, faulty velcro or laces that can’t be easily repaired, indicate the shoes are no longer safe or functional for climbing.
Summary: Time to Replace Your Shoes If…
- The shoe’s structure is damaged or deformed.
- The fit is no longer comfortable or precise.
- There’s wear in the midsole or areas that can’t be resoled.
- You’ve had several resoles and performance has dropped.
- You feel discomfort or pain during use.
Replacing your climbing shoes at the right time is essential for maintaining performance and safety on the wall.
